The Qui Tam Team Blog Join In the Fight Against Fraud

How Fraud Can Follow You

Do the names Richard Grasso and Mark Hurd mean anything to you? No? How about the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) and Hewlett-Packard (HP)? Still, no answer? Both Grasso and Hurd are former CEO’s of the companies mentioned, Grasso at NYSE and Hurd at HP. Grasso and HP committed fraud, and both Grasso and Hurd left their positions with damaged reputations. How about a more obscure name to those of us not in Florida: Rick Scott.

Scott is a Republican candidate running for Governor of Florida. A native of Illinois with no former experience in the government, Scott joined the gubernatorial race on April 9. The primary election for the Republican candidate for governor will take place on August 24. Scott is running against Bill McCollum, Attorney General of Florida, and Florida Senator Paula Dockery for the Republican candidacy. Due to Scott’s personal commitment of $4.7 million to his own campaign (more than McCollum has raised in a year), he has been able to buy advertising slots. Thanks to his ads, he is becoming increasingly popular as reflected in polls. Scott, in his few months in the race, only trails McCollum by 14 percentage points. The most recent Mason-Dixon poll, places McCollum at 38 percent and Scott at 24 percent. However, this 14 percent lead is not a good sign for McCollum according to Brad Coker, a Mason-Dixon pollster. He stated, “’McCollum’s 38-24 lead over Scott doesn’t look impressive given his long tenure and high visibility as a Republican office holder.’” McCollum’s place as the front-runner is not secure as Scott’s campaign gains more momentum and support.

Despite the fact that the author of this article has droned on about the race, the question remains, “why would this entry characterize Grasso of the NYSE, Hurd of HP, and new-to-the-political scene Scott, as similar to one another?” The key: the past will always be questioned in the future, and fraud will follow you in future endeavors. While Grasso and Hurd have left their respective companies, they have not decided to run for office. Scott, fraudulent company CEO on one hand, and self-proclaimed honest-politician on the other, is running. The largest Health Care Fraud case in U.S. History took place against Columbia/Hospital Corporation of America (HCA). Rick Scott was CEO of Columbia/HCA when the company committed fraud and during the time of the investigations.

Scott helped to found the Columbia Hospital Corporation in 1987, which merged with HCA in 1989. During Scott’s time as CEO, Columbia/HCA committed fraud against the government by improperly billing Medicare, Medicaid, and Tricare. The cases included evidence that Columbia/HCA overbilled, paid kickbacks, billed for treatments and drugs that weren’t covered and billed for hospitality costs not related to healthcare costs (sports tickets, country club dues, etc.) Scott resigned in 1997 after it was proven that the company kept two books: one that was shown to the government, and one that had listed the actual truthful expenses of the company. Columbia/HCA paid $1.7 billion to settle the case. According to the “Rick Scott for Governor” website when Scott left Columbia/HCA it was revered as “one of the most admired companies in America.” It is unknown how much the average American buys this statement, but then again, the website says nothing about the fraud committed.

Despite Scott’s position as CEO of a fraudulent company, he left with $10 million in severance, $300 million in stock options, spent $5 million to oppose President Obama’s healthcare plan, and it looks as through he will spend $25 in the governor’s race, according to Caputo. Scott was not charged or interviewed in the investigation of Columbia/HCA and claims that he “’denies the chain committed any criminal acts that he was aware of.” To be fair, it is possible that Scott did not know of the fraud committed when he was CEO. However, he has made it known that, “Mistakes were made at the company, and as CEO I have to accept responsibility for those mistakes.’”

So thirteen years after his resignation, Scott returns to the limelight, this time as an “honest-politician” instead of a “fraudulent company’s CEO.” However, Scott’s return certainly has not been easy, as his opponents (McCollum and Democratic frontrunner Alex Sink) have used the lawsuit against Columbia/HCA against him in attack ads. McCollum’s campaign stated that, “’The fact that Rick Scott is running for Governor as a ‘reformer’ would be funny if it wasn’t so outrageous…Rick Scott not only oversaw fraud, Rick Scott is fraud.’” However, when McCollum was in Congress during the investigation of Columbia/HCA, he noted that the crackdown on health care providers was overzealous, and sponsored the Health Care Claims Guidance Act, which tried to cut back on the investigations.

The company’s fraudulent activity aside, Scott thinks that his background prepares him for governor. While he may have a prestigious business background and be quite the entrepreneur, the fraud committed by Columbia/HCA will draw negative attention to his campaign. When asked why he’s running for governor when never holding a political position before, Scott answered, “‘I’m an outsider, I’m a business person, I know how to create private sector jobs, I know how to balance a budget.’” To Scott’s credit, he did create jobs as CEO of Columbia/HCA by employing 285,000 workers, making it the seventh largest employer in the U.S. at the time. But Scott’s budget-balancing skills may be in question when looking at Columbia/HCA’s budget under his watch. Scott responded further to the initial question stating, “‘I know how to get results by holding people accountable.’” This was probably not his best choice of words, considering those who hold him accountable for defrauding Medicare.

The most ironic part of the former-CEO-turned-politician’s campaign must be the type of fraud committed by Columbia/HCA with respect to the state that Scott is running in. William March of the Tampa Tribune was likely half serious, half joking, when he questioned, “Can the man who ran the company that committed the biggest Medicare fraud in history get elected governor in a state full of retirees?” This is an ironic possibility.

NOTE: This blog is meant to inform viewers of fraudulent activity and qui tam laws and lawsuits. The Qui Tam Team has no personal or professional feelings on Rick Scott’s campaign, nor the outcome of the election. This entry was written with the intention to educate, not to state an opinion.

Sources:
Appleby, Julie. “HCA to settle more allegations for $631M.” USA Today. 18 December 2002. http://www.usatoday.com/money/industries/health/2002-12-18-hca-settlement-_x.htm.
Caputo, Marc. “Poll: Former healthcare exec Rick Scott trails Bill McCollum in GOP primary.” The Miami Herald. 5 August 2010. http://www.miamiherald.com/2010/05/08/1620055/poll-former-healthcare-exec-rick.html.
March, William. “Rick Scott criticized for heading company that committed fraud.” The Tampa Tribune. 28 May 2010. http://www2.tbo.com/content/2010/may/28/281228/gop-candidate-scott-criticized-heading-company-com/news-politics/.
“Meet Rick.” Republican Rick Scott For Governor. 2010. http://www.rickscottforflorida.com/home/meet-rick/.

This article is brought to you by the QTT, the epicenter for whistleblowers and people interested in the False Claims Act, Qui Tam Provisions, and Medicare and Medicaid fraud. To discuss a potential case, please call Eric Young at 1 (800) 590-4116.